A Garden, A Maze, A Sematary*

In this second “potpour-reads” post, I share some quick thoughts on three recent reads, all of which were completed in May. The Secret Garden was a title on my Classics Club Challenge list. The Burning Maze is third in the Trials of Apollo series by Rick Riordan, and I read Pet Sematary because a new film adaptation is supposedly in the works and I tend to get caught up in that sort of thing. 

The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett

I recently read The Secret Garden as part of my Classics Club Challenge, after many years of seeing it come and go from my various TBR lifts and shelves. I’ve been meaning to read this book for years but have always put it off, probably because, subconsciously, I thought of it as a children’s book – a sorry excuse indeed because why should that matter? How many children’s books, especially classics, have I read and loved? Nevertheless, I have these tendencies, as I’m sure all readers do, to approach my reading with certain prejudices, and this being both a “child’s” book and a “girl’s” book, I wondered, isn’t it likely to be well beyond my interest at this point? Of course, then I actually started reading the book and couldn’t stop myself thinking, where has this book been all my life? Confession time? I guess I’m a bit of a reading diva, and it’s pretty stupid.

Anyhow, The Secret Garden begins in India under British colonial rule. We are introduced to the protagonist in this way: “When Mary Lennox was sent to Misselthwaite Manor to live with her uncle everybody said she was the most disagreeable-looking child ever seen. It was true, too.” Hilarious. Who begins a children’s book by dissing the main character’s appearance!? Something about that opening, and the honesty of the narrator throughout, drew me into the story and had me feeling equal hatred and empathy for little Mary and even little Colin, her cousin, both of whom are really rather terrible little brats at the beginning. But then a farm boy named Dickon starts to come around, and the secret garden is discovered, and the magic of humanity found in friendship, childish wonder, and the natural world begins to do its work. And it’s stunning and romantic in the best way imaginable.

For some reason, I thought this book was going to be more of a magical realism/mystery/fantasy kind of tale. It is actually firmly rooted in naturalism and realism; it is a coming-of-age tale that expresses magic in the everyday experience, and in the way children, even horribly disagreeable ones, can grow and change into wonderful people, given the right environment, the best challenges, and some great friends. I wasn’t expecting this kind of story, but it was exactly the kind I needed at the time of reading it. And Dickon, the nature sprite who is all things dirt and animal, plant and hill, is now one of my favorite characters of all-time. If Burnett had written a sequel from Dickon’s perspective, I could easily imagine it becoming a favorite of mine. The other characters, including the adults, are human enough and just present enough to matter without getting in the way of the children’s’ tale, which is and should be front and center. There are some very adult themes, a truly underlying sadness, and some dark commentary on colonialism, which makes reading this one as an adult all the more interesting and moving.

Now the real question: Should I watch the movie? Final Verdict: 4.0 out of 4.0.

The Burning Maze by Rick Riordan

The Burning Maze is Book Three in the Trials of Apollo series. Apollo has been sent to earth in the form of a pudgy, pimply teenage boy, largely without any kind of godly power at all, and is tasked with helping the Roman and Greek demigods fight the horrors of the Triad: three evil, dangerous, and powerful former Roman Emperors with plans to take over the world. Beneath their plot, even, lies the power of Apollo’s most feared antagonist, Python, the god of snakes. As is typical with Riordan’s books, the pace is fast and the plot is fun. There is a lot to learn regarding roman mythology, especially, and that is always exciting for me. There is also a bit of tragedy in this third book, one that the reader is somewhat eased into but that is nevertheless difficult for those who have been invested in the two Roman series’ so far.

In this third installment, we learn much more about Meg, the twelve-year-old demigod who is essentially Apollo’s “master,” and her background. Some old and familiar characters from other books in this series, as well as the Percy Jackson and Heroes of Olympus series’, reappear. As with many of the other books, this one follows a certain formula that readers of Riordan’s books should come to expect; Burning Maze even revisits one of the original Percy Jackson battlegrounds, the Labyrinth, but in this case the visit is short and sweet, and the maze then becomes an underlying menace rather than a place of action for the entire plot.

Riordan has also taken more and more chances with his books over the years, something he began with (I think) the Heroes of Olympus series and then carried over into the Magnus Chase books (I have not kept up with the Kane Chronicles, unfortunately, so I can’t speak to that one). Riordan is an outspoken LGBTQ ally, for example, and a number of LGBTQ+ characters have been written into the stories, some major and some minor. This has been extraordinarily exciting to witness in the middle grade genre, and it has been particularly effective, I think, because Riordan does a nice job of delicately handling the reality of “coming out” with the kinds of reactions his queer characters receive from other characters, mostly accepting but sometimes with shock, wonder, curiosity, etc. The humor is still excellent, as are the character relationships. One of the most interesting and rewarding elements is the way that Apollo is growing from book-to-book. One of the themes of all the Riordan novels is how flippantly the gods take their relationships with humanity and their human children. The fascinating piece of this series is that we have a god who has been made human and who is now experiencing all that it is to be human, which is changing him in very profound ways. It is a smart and meaningful take on the modern myth series. Final Verdict: 3.25 out of 4.0.

Pet Sematary by Stephen King

I was going to check my Goodreads account to see how many King novels I have read so far and where this one falls in that line, but I realized it would take more time than I’m willing to give it. We’ll just say, I’ve read a lot of Stephen King. The reason why I like King so much is actually not because I like horror/thrillers (it’s quite frankly not a genre I read very often). Instead, I like King because he has so much to say about the human psyche and human instinct. Pet Sematary is considered to be one of King’s most chilling horror novels and, while I don’t think it’s really his scariest or goriest or any of that, I can agree with the assessmentbecauseit treats the human condition in such an honest, and horrible, way.

The book is about Dr. Louis Creed and his young family, all of whom move to Ludlow, Maine so that Creed can take a job as a University physician. The majority of the novel is background, character building, and scene-setting. Almost all of the real action, the terror, takes place in the third and final section, which is much shorter than the first two. This helps create a false sense of security throughout most of the book while simultaneously allowing the ending to be much more dramatic and exhilarating, even unexpected (if anything from King can be considered unexpected – maybe that’s silly!) The horror begins when Creed’s daughter’s cat is killed and Creed’s neighbor, perhaps against his will, shares a secret that is better left unknown. This sets forth a series of ominous events that increase in impact and effect, until at last, a force beyond anyone’s control grips Ludlow, especially the Creeds, and begins to pull all the strings.

Pet Sematary was written between 1979-1982 and then published in 1983. King was reluctant to send it out to his publishers because he himself was so concerned with what he wrote, and it is not hard to understand why. Few popular novels that I can think of at this time so honestly and deeply addressed the lengths to which a person will go in order to ease an unthinkably painful emotional and psychological burden. Creed is suffering the worst pain imaginable, as is his wife, and his grief causes him to be compelled further and further down a path he knows is horribly dangerous and morally wrong. How can a man be driven to make all the wrong steps? In small increments and through tiny justifications and false ratiocination (as Poe would call them), until, without realizing what is happening, the decisions have been made and the actions have been taken, and all hell has broken loose.

Pet Sematary reminded me very much of King’s other most popular of horror novels, IT. The ominous force is even described as “IT” –an unnamed thing—and various points in the novel. I wonder if King was already working on that idea as early as 1979, even though IT itself did not appear until 1986. There are so many similarities, but the most prominent is the theme of evil as an uncontrollable force of human nature: good and smart and decent people being compelled to do terrible things. What is scarier than that? Final Verdict: 3.5 out of 4.0. 

22 Comments on “A Garden, A Maze, A Sematary*

  1. I’m so glad you loved The Secret Garden! I am well overdue a reread. As to the film – I like it, but (if I remember correctly) it does dip into magical realism a bit more than the book does, and it also seems to be hinting at a love triangle between its three child characters – which seems a bit unnecessary to me. The shots of the moor and the garden are wonderful, though, and Maggie Smith is in it and she’s wonderful.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. The film of The Secret Garden (1992, with Maggie Smith) is really utterly beautiful, and faithful to the book (except for how Mary’s parents die, right at the beginning)—I’d highly recommend it.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. The Secret Garden was one of my favorite childhood books and I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve read it – and I have also found that it holds up in adulthood. Glad to hear you enjoyed it! The Trials of Apollo series sounds good, too – I’ve read the Percy Jackson books and the first Magnus Chase, but want to get to the rest of Riordan’s books. One of these days!

    Liked by 1 person

    • You’ll want to read The Heroes of Olympus series before Trials of Apollo because there are characters from Percy and Heroes in Apollo. 🙂


  4. The Secret Garden is one of my favorite books, and Mary my favorite characters. I love that Mary gets things done because of her faults, not in spite of them — similar to Meg in Wrinkle in Time. And I love the power of nature theme, because I feel the same way a lot of the time. The 1993 movie is quite good, though it’s hard to do the book justice.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Good point about how our pre-conceived notions/prejudices get in the way of a good experience. i’ve been guilty of that when it comes to science fiction, mainly I suspect because i just dont understand science very well. But then I read Station Eleven and was bowled over by how good it was and i didn’t need to understand science at all….

    Liked by 1 person

  6. The Secret Garden is one of my favourite books (was as a child and is now as well)– simply loved the er ‘scene’ where Mary outscreams Colin, and of course, the ‘magic’ of the garden itself!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I read The Secret Garden as an adult also, maybe four years ago and absolutely loved it. Dickon was one of my favorite characters. Boy would I love to take a walk on the moors with him pointing out all the plants. From him I learned another name for daffodils and every spring I often say in my mind, “look at the daffydowndillys!”

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes! That character makes me wish I could go back in time and find a friend like him. (Or be like him! Although, we didn’t have anything quite like a moor in my suburban Chicago neighborhood).


  8. “If tha’ was a missel thrush an’ showed me where thy nest was, does tha’ think I’d tell any one? Not me,” he said. “Tha’ art as safe as a missel thrush.”

    Liked by 2 people

  9. Oh yes, there really are some wonderful classics to be found in the realm of children’s literature, such as the case with The Secret Garden. Some of these kind of stories may seem simple, but they hold so many valuable truths and lessons… it’s soooo good to read!

    On a somewhat similar note, I’d just like to mention I’m hosting a Louisa May Alcott reading challenge this month. If you’re interested, just stop by blog for the details. 🙂



  10. I found the second Apollo book okay, so I’m glad to hear you liked the third. A nitpick, though: Trials of Apollo (and Magnus Chase) are not middle grade, but YA, though the first Percy Jackson series and Kane Chronicles are.

    I agree about Riordan and his allyship. I remember thinking during one of the Heroes of Olympus books that it was SO heteronormative and, like, two chapters later he revealed that Nico was gay. Not to mention the inclusion of kids of color, acknowledgment of various cultures’ mythologies and histories, plus that he created his imprint? True ally ✊🏾

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for your thoughts. I stick by my classification as Middle Grade, though. Or perhaps “high middle grade.” Barnes and Noble and Junior Library Guild both classify it as Children’s/MG for ages 10-14, and MG is typically 8-12. So, for me, these aren’t quite YA (which covers more of the 13-18 range). Or perhaps Riordan has given us the need for a new classification range. MG+/YA-

      Liked by 1 person

      • I think we have needed that classification since Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire came out, tbh.

        Liked by 3 people

      • Yes, agreed! Part of the genius of that series is how he narratives themselves advanced as the characters/original audience grew up.

        Liked by 2 people

  11. Pingback: 2018 End of Year Book Survey | Roof Beam Reader

  12. Pingback: Stephen King’s The Institute

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: